A 14-year-old boy has pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the fatal stabbing of Shahnaz Pestonji, a 71-year-old retired nurse killed during an attempted carjacking in North York in July 2025. The case shocked the Greater Toronto Area and triggered a three-day police manhunt before the teen’s arrest.
A Violent Attack in a Parking Lot
Pestonji had just finished grocery shopping at a store on Parkway Forest Drive on July 17, 2025, around 9:23 a.m. A witness told police he saw a male suspect dressed in all black approach her as she loaded bags into her Toyota Corolla. Moments later, the witness heard her scream. The suspect stabbed her once on the left side of her chest, then fled eastbound through the plaza. Pestonji died from that single stab wound.
Stay connected to every major update — subscribe and follow us on the PhoenixQ website and across our social media platforms.
Surveillance footage shown in court captured the attack. Assistant Crown attorney Andrea McPhedran described the video as “hard to watch.” It shows the teen, who was taller and larger than Pestonji, grabbing her in a bear hug to take her keys. He then dragged her between two parked vehicles before stabbing her. McPhedran called it “a callous and unduly violent attack” on an innocent woman simply going about her day.
Victim Impact and Family Grief
Pestonji had been married for 47 years, raised two daughters, and worked as a nurse for 28 years caring for veterans at Sunnybrook Health Centre. Her family chose not to attend court, finding it too difficult.
Three victim impact statements were read aloud. Her husband, identified as S. Pestonji, described her as his best friend and the love of his life. “She was a remarkable woman. Humble, kind, caring, compassionate,” he wrote. “I still enjoy listening to dance music but I don’t dance anymore because the person I dance with is no longer here.” One of her daughters, Y. Pestonji, who was 33 weeks pregnant at the time of the murder, wrote: “This unprovoked act of violence did not just kill my mother, it completely shattered my world.”
How Police Tracked the Suspect
Investigators traced the teen through TTC surveillance footage. The day before the stabbing, he had visited Bay Station unmasked to claim a lost phone at the lost and found. After the attack, he discarded his jacket in a nearby garbage bin. Police recovered it and sent it to the Centre for Forensic Sciences. Pestonji’s blood was found on the jacket.
On July 19, police received a tip that the teen was in Scarborough. That evening, he appeared on a live Instagram feed, where he stated he had been out of custody for one to two weeks. He also discussed the stabbing, saying, “I didn’t even mean to f-in kill the old lady” and “she didn’t give me the keys so I yoked her.” Officers from the Emergency Task Force responded but the teen escaped after a stolen vehicle he was in collided with a police car. Police arrested him the following day, July 20, without incident.
Proposed Sentence and Mental Health Findings
The Crown and defence jointly proposed the maximum youth sentence of seven years under the Youth Criminal Justice Act. Four years would be served in custody, followed by three years of community supervision. The only dispute is whether the teen should receive credit for the 19 months he has already served since his arrest.
The teen, now 15, qualifies for an intensive rehabilitative custody and supervision order due to diagnosed mental health conditions. These include oppositional defiance disorder, conduct disorder, ADHD, and substance use disorders. He also has a history of suicide attempts and self-harm. Court heard he had witnessed five gun violence deaths, been in over ten police chase accidents, and joined a gang around age 10. He reportedly participated in home invasions from age 12. Just 10 days before the stabbing, he had been released from a youth facility after a guilty plea for vehicle theft. The judge has reserved her sentencing decision to a later date.
English


























































