Sotheby’s set a new single-night record on Wednesday, bringing in a combined $777.8 million across two consecutive Impressionist and modern art auctions in New York. The total surpasses the $706 million the house achieved last November during its inaugural evening double-header at the Breuer building.
Van Gogh and Cézanne Lead Historic Collection Sale
The first auction featured 12 works from the Blaquier-Arrieta collection, which together realized $412 million. That figure fell just short of the presale low estimate of $414.5 million. Even so, the sale set a record for a single-owner Impressionist and modern art evening sale at Sotheby’s.
Stay connected to every major update — subscribe and follow us on the PhoenixQ website and across our social media platforms.
The two most anticipated works were Vincent van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en fleurs (1890) and Paul Cézanne’s Arlequin (1888–90). The van Gogh sold for $190.4 million, making it the highest price ever achieved at Sotheby’s and the highest price ever paid for a van Gogh at auction. The Cézanne followed at $111 million, the second-highest auction price for that artist.
However, both works hammered below their presale estimates. Bidding on the van Gogh drew only a handful of offers. The Cézanne attracted just four bids, alternating between Sotheby’s specialists Lisa Dennison and Helena Newman, with Newman securing the final bid. When asked whether a restitution claim against the van Gogh had dampened interest, Sotheby’s CEO Charles Stewart said he did not believe so. “I think you have to separate auction heat from auction results,” he said.
Multiple Records Fall in the Evening’s Second Sale
The second auction, featuring 47 lots from multiple owners, generated far more competitive bidding. It raised $365.8 million, with only one lot going unsold and 33 Sotheby’s specialists fielding phone bids throughout.
Edward Hopper’s 1944 seascape The Martha McKeen of Wellfleet, from the collection of Baroness Carmen Thyssen-Bornemisza, topped that sale at $47.8 million including fees. While well below Hopper’s record of $91.8 million set at Christie’s in 2018, it stands as his second-highest auction price. René Magritte’s 1964 painting L’Ami de l’ordre sold close behind for $45 million. Collector Sydell Miller had purchased it in 1998 for $5.3 million. The result also surpassed the previous record for a Magritte bowler hat painting, set at Christie’s London in March 2024 for approximately $43.2 million.
Aaron Douglas’s 1931 portrait of Harriet Tubman delivered one of the evening’s most dramatic moments. Estimated at $2.5 million to $3.5 million, it sold for $14.1 million — more than quadrupling its high estimate and shattering Douglas’s previous record of $600,000. All proceeds go to Bennett College, a historically Black women’s college. Meanwhile, Mary Cassatt’s Summertime (1894–95) sold for $13.3 million to an online bidder, nearly doubling her previous auction record of $7.5 million.
Criticism Over Guarantee Strategy
Not everyone viewed the evening positively. Phillip Hoffman, founder and chairman of the Fine Art Group, criticized Sotheby’s use of guarantees on all Blaquier lots. “The guarantees were just too high,” he told ARTnews. He suggested the house may have lost as much as $50 million on guarantees due to limited buyer competition. Stewart acknowledged the house’s confidence in its pricing but defended the outcome. “Our estimates weren’t shy,” he said. “We were happy with the result of everything.”
Additionally, three lots — works by Magritte, Cézanne, and Matisse — were withdrawn during the sale without prior announcement. Two of those came from the collection of hedge fund founder George Weiss, who is currently in bankruptcy proceedings.
English



























































